top of page

The Smallest Witness: Justin Hofman’s “Sewage Surfer” (2016)

Writer: Seoyoung Kim
Seoyoung Kim
Oct 1
2 min read


The seahorse in Justin Hofman’s photograph is about 3.8 centimeters (1.5 inches) long. It floats in green-blue water off Indonesia, its tiny curled tail wrapped around something bright pink: a plastic cotton swab. At first glance it seems almost whimsical, a small creature riding a colorful stick like a toy. A second later the viewer understands what they are seeing. The ocean is full of our trash, and its smallest inhabitants are holding on to it.


Hofman, a California nature photographer, took the picture in December 2016 near Sumbawa in Indonesia’s Lesser Sunda Islands. A colleague pointed out the seahorse, and Hofman later described smelling and tasting the pollution in the water. At first the seahorse held on to sea grass, then grabbed a piece of plastic bag, and finally settled on the swab. Seahorses survive by gripping objects with their tails as they drift, so the animal was doing what its species has always done. What had changed was what was available to hold on to.


The photograph became a finalist in London’s Natural History Museum Wildlife Photographer of the Year competition in 2017, under the title “Sewage Surfer,” and it spread rapidly online. Part of its power is its gentleness. Many environmental images rely on horror: oil-soaked birds, emaciated animals, wildlife killed by plastic. Hofman’s seahorse isn’t dying or visibly suffering. The image disturbs instead by quietly mixing two worlds that should never meet: a creature of extraordinary delicacy and one of the most disposable objects in the bathroom cabinet.


Hofman himself was uncomfortable with the picture’s success. He said he wished it “didn’t exist,” but that since it did, he felt responsible for showing it to as many people as possible. That tension, between making a beautiful image and wishing its subject had never happened, runs through much environmental photography. A photographer can’t take credit for the scene without also documenting a loss. In Hofman’s framing, the success of the photograph was a measure of the failure it recorded.


The image also arrived at a turning point in plastic policy. In the years that followed, the European Union and the United Kingdom moved to ban plastic-stemmed cotton buds along with other single-use plastic items, and cotton swabs became one of the clearest examples of how small, everyday plastics reach the ocean, often flushed down toilets and slipping through sewage treatment. No single photograph can claim credit for policy, but “Sewage Surfer” gave the debate a memorable face.


What makes the image endure is its scale. Ocean plastic is usually pictured as a vast, abstract problem: garbage patches, millions of tonnes, statistics too large to feel. Hofman shrank it to a single animal and a single piece of trash. The seahorse doesn’t know it is holding our waste. It is just holding on. And that may be the most unsettling message of all: the natural world isn’t rejecting what we have dumped into it. It is adapting to it, and building our trash into everyday life.

Comments


bottom of page