top of page

What the Science on Fungal Networks Really Shows

Writer: Dohyeon Lee
Dohyeon Lee
6 days ago
3 min read

Few scientific ideas have charmed the public like the “wood wide web.” In the popular version, trees in a forest are connected underground by threads of fungi. Through this network they share sugar, send warnings about insect attacks, and in the most moving version, old “mother trees” feed and protect their own seedlings. The idea has filled bestselling books, inspired films, and even appeared on Ted Lasso. It reframes the forest as a community rather than a battlefield. But how much of it is actually true?


Part of it is solid science. Most trees form partnerships with mycorrhizal fungi, which wrap around or grow into roots. The fungi help trees absorb water and nutrients, and in exchange the trees give them sugar. That relationship is well established and essential to how forests work. A common mycorrhizal network forms when the fungal threads connect the roots of several plants of the same or different species underground. Such networks have been scientifically proven to exist. The controversy is over what they do.


In 2023, three mycorrhizal researchers, Justine Karst, Melanie Jones, and Jason Hoeksema, published a review in Nature Ecology & Evolution that tested the most popular claims against the field evidence. Their conclusions were blunt. The claims that these networks are widespread in forests and that resources moving through them improve seedling performance are insufficiently supported, because field results vary too widely, have other possible explanations, or are too limited to generalize. The claim that mature trees preferentially send resources and defense signals to their offspring through the networks has no peer-reviewed, published evidence. On seedlings in particular, they found roughly equal evidence that connecting to a network helps or hurts them, with neutral effects reported most often.


The review’s sharper point was about how science gets told. The authors examined how network research is cited and found that unsupported claims doubled over the past 25 years, suggesting a bias toward citing positive effects. In other words, the story grew partly because each retelling, in popular books and in academic papers alike, made it slightly more confident than the evidence beneath it. Researchers associated with the “mother tree” idea, including forest ecologist Suzanne Simard, have defended their work, and the debate continues. The core finding is not that fungal networks are a myth. It is that the most appealing parts of the story are ahead of the data.


This matters beyond scientific accuracy. Karst and her colleagues warned that distorting the science is a problem because sound evidence is critical for deciding how forests are managed, and it is premature to base forest practices and policies on these networks without further proof. If logging rules, replanting strategies, or conservation campaigns are built on claims that turn out to be wrong, forests could end up worse off. Failing to identify misinformation can also erode public trust in science.


None of this makes forests less remarkable. The real world under our feet is strange enough: fungi trading nutrients with roots, chemical signals moving through soil, complex relationships science is still mapping. The lesson of the wood wide web is not to stop wondering at nature. It is to hold even our favorite stories about it to the same standard as any other claim, and to be most careful with the ones we most want to believe.

Comments


bottom of page