top of page

Hydrogen’s Hype Cycle: What Green Hydrogen Can and Can’t Do

Writer: Jane Park
Jane Park
Oct 1
3 min read

Few clean-energy technologies have been promoted as heavily as hydrogen. It burns without producing carbon dioxide, and the only exhaust is water. It can be made from water and renewable electricity. In theory it can power cars, heat homes, run steel mills, and fuel ships and planes. Over the past decade, governments launched national hydrogen strategies, oil companies announced gigawatt-scale projects, and “hydrogen economy” became a standard phrase in climate plans. The reality has turned out to be far more limited, and understanding why matters for spending climate money well.


The first thing to know is that the world already uses a lot of hydrogen, and almost none of it is clean. Global hydrogen demand reached almost 100 million tonnes in 2024, mainly for oil refining and making ammonia fertilizer. Nearly all of it is made from natural gas or coal, producing substantial carbon emissions. Low-emissions hydrogen, made either with renewable power or from fossil fuels with carbon capture, grew 10% in 2024 but still accounts for less than 1% of global production.


The project pipeline has been shrinking. In its 2025 Global Hydrogen Review, the International Energy Agency reported that potential low-emissions hydrogen production by 2030 from announced projects had fallen to 37 million tonnes a year, down from 49 million a year earlier. It was the first downward revision since the review began in 2021. Developers have shelved projects across Africa, the Americas, Europe, and Australia. The core problem is cost: producing hydrogen from fossil fuels remains much cheaper, and that cost gap is a key barrier to clean projects.


Physics explains much of the gap. Making hydrogen by splitting water with electricity loses a large share of the energy. Compressing, storing, and transporting it loses more, because hydrogen is the smallest molecule there is, leaks easily, and makes some metals brittle. Turning it back into electricity in a fuel cell loses more still. By the time green hydrogen moves a car, most of the original renewable electricity is gone. A battery-electric vehicle does the same job using roughly a third as much power. Heating homes with hydrogen has similar problems compared with electric heat pumps. Hydrogen also isn’t climate-neutral when it leaks, because it extends the lifetime of methane and other greenhouse gases in the atmosphere.


None of this means hydrogen has no role. It means the role is narrower than the hype suggested. Energy analysts often describe a “hydrogen ladder,” ranking uses from most to least sensible. At the top are uses where hydrogen is already needed or where there are few alternatives: replacing dirty hydrogen in fertilizer plants and refineries, making steel without coal, and producing fuels such as ammonia or methanol for long-distance shipping. At the bottom are uses where batteries and direct electrification already work better: cars, home heating, and most short-range transport. Most of the clean hydrogen expected by 2030 is aimed at the upper end of the ladder: chemicals, refining, and low-emissions fuels.


Geography is shifting as well. China currently leads global deployment of electrolyzers for low-emissions hydrogen, with 65% of installed or committed capacity and nearly 60% of manufacturing capacity, repeating the pattern seen in solar panels and batteries. The lesson of the hydrogen hype cycle isn’t that the technology failed. It’s that clean energy is a matter of efficiency and choosing where each tool fits best. Hydrogen is valuable for a few difficult jobs, and treating it as an all-purpose solution wasted time and money that could have gone to options already ready to use.

Comments


bottom of page