The Most Wasteful Land Use in America: Parking


Look at an aerial photo of almost any American city and you will see a surprising amount of gray. Surface lots surround shopping centers. Parking garages take up whole downtown blocks. Driveways, curbs, and garages fill residential streets. In many US cities, more land is devoted to storing cars than to housing people. Very little of this happened by market demand. Much of it is required by law. For decades, zoning codes across the country have mandated minimum numbers of parking spaces for nearly every kind of building, and that policy has shaped cities in ways most people never notice.
These rules are called parking minimums. A typical code might require a set number of spaces per apartment, per thousand square feet of retail, or per restaurant seat. The figures often came from surveys of suburban sites at peak demand, then were copied from city to city. UCLA planning professor Donald Shoup, whose book The High Cost of Free Parking became the foundational text of the reform movement, spent decades documenting how these requirements were set with little evidence and produced enormous unintended consequences.
The first consequence is cost. Parking is expensive to build, especially in dense cities. In Chicago, a city report estimated the average cost of a space in an underground garage at $67,500. That cost is passed on to residents and customers whether or not they own a car, which makes housing more expensive for everyone and is especially unfair to people who don’t drive. Parking requirements also make many small buildings impossible: a narrow city lot often can’t fit both a building and its mandated parking, so the project never gets built.
The environmental consequences are just as large. Requiring parking spreads buildings farther apart, which makes walking and transit less practical and car ownership more necessary. Large paved lots absorb heat and make cities hotter, and they increase stormwater runoff, which overwhelms sewer systems and pollutes rivers. They also take land that could hold housing, trees, or businesses. Parking minimums effectively subsidize driving and push cities toward car-dependent growth.
The good news is that this is one of the fastest-changing areas of urban policy. On July 16, 2025, the Chicago City Council unanimously ended parking mandates for most new development near public transit. The ordinance removed parking requirements for any use within a quarter mile of a frequent bus route or half a mile of a rail station, and the change took effect that September. Chicago joined cities including Anchorage, Minneapolis, and Austin, while Denver went further, eliminating minimums citywide for all development. Illinois has since moved to limit parking mandates near transit statewide.
Ending parking minimums doesn’t ban parking. Developers can still build as much as they think their tenants or customers need. It simply lets the market, rather than an outdated formula, decide. Cities that have made the change are watching to see whether it produces more housing, lower costs, and more walkable neighborhoods, as reformers expect. The broader lesson is that sustainability doesn’t depend only on new technology. Sometimes it depends on repealing old rules that quietly made cities more expensive, hotter, and more dependent on cars.



Comments